Rebellions of 1837 justified or not

Poor harvests reduced numerous many farmers to poverty. Howe was deeply disappointed when the government refused to reform the colonial parliamentary system.

These reformists were opposed by the pro-British forces, the English colonial authorities and their strong-arm men of the Doric Club. By December of his high opinion of the American Republic was leading him to believe that the American Revolution might be the only practical example of how change might be effected in Upper Canada.

In 1837, were the Canadian rebels justified in taking up arms against the official government?

Barricaded in the town church they were bombarded for hours, a cannonade in which the local priest participated. The second battle, at Saint-Charles-sur-Richelieu, resulted in a crushing defeat for the Patriots. Posted on by philipa We know that the rebellion of happened because the people were complaining about the government systems.

This time they clearly called Rebellions of 1837 justified or not a republic, and issued a Declaration of Independence, written by Dr.

Upon his return to London inJohn George Lambton, the Earl of Durham tabled his report, which outlined the conclusions he had drawn during his stay in the British colonies of North America. There shall be one Legislative Council and one Assembly. Seeing that defeat was inevitable, Nelson fled the scene for the US and, with this; the Patriots Rebellion came to an end.

He finally retired in and resigned his seat in after seeing many of the goals he had worked for either achieved or within reach of being achieved. The lower Canadian rebels would have their crops and fields burned. Ashley Kannan Certified Educator From looking at it from the rebels point of view, they felt justified in taking up arms against the official government.

Hearing nothing, the troops dispersed. But however looking at art 1, it says: He quickly became a folk hero among the common man in Upper Canada who generally felt that he was right about the family compact and that something should be done.

His aggressive and direct attacks upon the Family Compact brought an immediate response with threats of legal action, libel suits and an attack upon his newspaper office where his printing presses were broken and thrown into Lake Ontario.

The report stated that the conflict was between two races or nations of people living in a single state.

The Rebellions Of Upper And Lower Canada

The compact mounted a strong campaign against him in the legislative election and he was defeated. They proposed a non-violent strategy of confrontation such as boycotting British goods. The leader of the Patriots, Papineau, was not in the town. Papineau did not call for open revolt, though others, like the Anglo-Canadian Dr.

The report stated that the conflict was between two races or nations of people living in a single state. The troops pillaged and ransacked Saint-Eustache.

Papineau continued to push for reform. It took three years for the British government to respond to the 92 resolutions, and when they did — with the so-called 10 resolutions — it was a stinging rejection of the Canadian demands.

Later inthe Parti Patriote swept the election, gaining more than three-quarters of the popular vote. In the meantime, filibusters from the United States, the Hunter Patriotsformed a small militia and attacked Windsor, Upper Canadato support the Canadian Patriots.

Though at this point many of the principal Patriot leaders fled Canada for exile in the US, the resistance to the British was not yet over. They came streaming down Young Street looking to destroy compact property and business as an act of defiance and potentially trigger a large scale rebellion.

Also Elgin wanted to introduce enough democracy to the citizens of the new nation so there would not be a revolution. Papineau, from his American exile, remained optimistic: The following year, leaders who had escaped across the border into the United States raided Lower Canada in February Rebellion losses bill was enacted to compensate eastern Canadians who lost property during the Rebellions of And it showed us why the government systems back in their time was not succeeding with the people.

The first armed conflict occurred in when the 26 members of the Patriote movement, who had been charged with illegal activities, chose to resist their arrest by the authorities under the direction of John Colborne.Cause and Effect: The Canadian Rebellions of and Words | 7 Pages.

The research in this proposal primarily focuses on the rebellions that took place in both upper and Lower Canada during Papineau did not call for open revolt, though others, like the Anglo-Canadian Dr. Wolfred Nelson, said that the “time has come to melt our plates and our tin spoons to make bullets.

” Finally, on November 23, armed rebellion began, when Patriot troops led by Wolfred Nelson defeated British troops in the Richelieu valley town of Saint-Denis.

Nov 20,  · Is Armed Rebellion Ever Justifiable? 10 POINTS Easy? By comparison, the upper and lower Canadian rebellions of / 38 were minor uprisings. Perhaps the biggest difference is that though the small group of radicals who started these rebellions were against various policies of the English, they did not have the grand Status: Resolved.

The Rebellions of - The rebellions in Lower Canada that took place in were aimed at gaining greater independence from Great Britain. The cause of the rebellions were numerous.

The Lower Canada Rebellion (French: La rébellion du Bas-Canada), commonly referred to as the Patriots' War (French: La Guerre des patriotes) by Quebecers, is the name given to the armed conflict in –38 between the rebels of Lower Canada (now Quebec) and the British colonial power of that province.

• differentiatecause,antecedent!event,consequenceandafterthefact!event! relatedtotheRebellionsof

Rebellions of 1837 justified or not
Rated 3/5 based on 22 review